11 Purdeys Way, Rochford, England, SS4 1ND
Home / Relevant Life Cover / Relevant Life Insurance vs Shareholder Protection
While Relevant Life Insurance and Shareholder Protection both provide financial security, they serve different purposes. Relevant Life Insurance is used to protect the employee’s beneficiaries, whereas Shareholder Protection is used to protect existing shareholders and helps maintain company stability.
Let’s take a closer look at Relevant Life vs Shareholder Protection to help you find the most suitable protection for your staff and business. We’ll look at the benefits of both types of insurance, along with what you can expect from both Shareholder Protection and Relevant Life cover.
Relevant Life Insurance is a tax-efficient life insurance policy taken out by a business to provide life cover for an employee or director. If the insured employee unexpectedly passes away, a lump sum is paid to their beneficiaries, which can be used to cover expenses such as mortgage or rent, utility bills and childcare.
Some of the features of Relevant Life Insurance include:
Shareholder Protection Insurance ensures that the remaining shareholders have the financial means to purchase the deceased’s shares if a shareholder dies. This prevents ownership from passing to other parties and helps the business maintain stability.
One of the advantages of Relevant Life Cover is its tax benefits. Premiums are usually considered a business expense, which reduces Corporation Tax for the company. Employees also don’t pay Income Tax or National Insurance on the insurance premiums, nor Inheritance Tax if the payouts are placed in a discretionary trust.
Relevant Life Insurance is designed for small and medium businesses that may not qualify for large group life insurance schemes. The insurance allows directors and key employees to have life insurance that is paid for by the company and protects their beneficiaries in the event of their death.
The cover for Relevant Life Insurance is typically based on the insured director or employee’s salary and therefore can offer significant levels of cover. Some policies also include additional benefits such as Business Care and Medical Services.
The main benefit of Shareholder Protection is that it prevents shares from passing to an unintended party, such as family members of the deceased. This helps the business maintain stability by keeping control with the remaining shareholders.
Shareholder Protection can fund an agreed purchase of a deceased shareholder’s interest. The purchaser may be the surviving shareholders or, under a separately structured company share purchase, the company itself. The policy, valuation and legal agreement need to match that route.
Ask what you need the payout to achieve. Relevant Life Insurance provides family protection. Shareholder Protection helps fund the purchase of a shareholder’s interest under the agreed ownership arrangements.
A two-director company may need both: Relevant Life cover for each director’s family and Shareholder Protection so the surviving owner has funds to buy the deceased’s shares. The family benefit and the share purchase solve different problems.
The insurance and legal agreement must work together. Our cross-option agreement guide explains how a share purchase can be arranged. Neither policy replaces Key Person Insurance for a loss of business profits.
Here at My Key Man Insurance, we can help you find and compare the most suitable insurance to protect your company and staff. As an insurance broker, we compare various insurance providers and deals to provide tailored coverage for your company, directors and employees. Contact us for help and advice finding the most suitable Shareholder Protection and Relevant Life Cover for your company. We can also help you find other types of business insurance, including Business Loan Protection and Director Life Insurance.
No, Relevant Life policies can’t be used for Shareholder Protection. UK law requires Relevant Life policies to meet certain criteria; Relevant Life Insurance must be used to benefit the employee’s family, not the company or shareholders.
One of the main differences between Relevant Life vs Shareholder Protection is who benefits from the payout. Relevant Life Insurance pays a lump sum to the insured director or employee’s beneficiaries, while Shareholder Protection helps the company secure the shares of a deceased or ill shareholder.
Relevant Life Insurance may be transferred to the individual if they leave the company, which allows them to continue the coverage personally. Meanwhile, Shareholder Protection usually ends for a shareholder if they leave, as their shareholding in the business changes. The company may need to set up a new agreement for new shareholders.
Shareholder Protection can include critical illness cover to fund a share purchase under the agreed terms. Relevant Life is primarily family life protection; an Employee Significant Illness option is a separately defined benefit, not ordinary critical illness cover. Check our significant illness explanation before comparing.

“Family protection and a funded share purchase can both matter to the same director. I keep those needs separate so neither the family nor the surviving owners are relying on money intended for someone else.”
Written by Jody Pearmain, Director of My Key Finance Ltd. Business protection specialist since 2008. About Jody.